The Capitol LedgerEvery move in Congress, on the record
HomeBillsRecordsLedger AI

The Capitol Ledger

Built from the Congressional Record and Congress.gov. Every summary links to its source.

AboutFAQFeedbackTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
Follow us onlineInstagram

Summaries are AI-generated from primary sources. Verify anything important against the original record.

The Capitol Ledger

Built from the Congressional Record and Congress.gov. Every summary links to its source.

The projectAboutFAQFeedback
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
Follow us onlineInstagram

Summaries are AI-generated from primary sources. Verify anything important against the original record.

All bills
6 versions
CosmeticWhat changed in PUBLIC LAWcompared with ENROLLED BILL

Technical corrections only. v6 updates the enrolled bill (v5) to its Public Law format, including the addition of U.S. Code citations, legislative notes, approval date, and legislative history. No substantive policy changes were made between the two versions.

H.R. 3497·119th Congress·Introduced May 19, 2025

Medal of Sacrifice Act

Became Public LawCrime and Law EnforcementSubstantive
View bill text
Sponsor
Rep. Mast, Brian J. [R-FL-21]
Committees
Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee (primary)
Last action
May 28, 2026

Bottom line

This Act creates a national medal to honor law enforcement officers and first responders who die in the line of duty, with a commission to oversee its implementation and eligibility, including a process for reviewing cases of alleged wrongdoing.

What it actually does

This Act establishes a national 'Medal of Sacrifice' to honor law enforcement officers and first responders who are killed in the line of duty. It creates a 12-member Commission to advise on the medal's design, promotion, and presentation, and to determine eligibility, especially in cases involving alleged wrongdoing. The Act also names three initial recipients of the medal.

Proponents argue

Supporters argue this bill provides long-overdue national recognition and honor for the ultimate sacrifice made by law enforcement officers and first responders, offering a tangible symbol of gratitude to their families and acknowledging their critical role in public safety. They contend it fills a gap in federal honors for these essential public servants.

Opponents contend

Critics might argue that while the sentiment is noble, the creation of a new federal commission and medal adds to bureaucratic overhead without addressing underlying systemic issues faced by first responders. Some might also raise concerns about the 'official finding of wrongdoing' exception and the Commission's power to make final eligibility determinations, potentially leading to subjective or politically influenced decisions in sensitive cases.

The bill is very short and easily digestible, allowing ample time for a thorough understanding of its provisions.

Section 2(a)

Creation of the Medal of Sacrifice

prominently featuredstraightforward

This provision mandates the President to issue a 'Medal of Sacrifice' specifically for local, State, Tribal, territorial, or Federal law enforcement officers and first responders who are killed while performing their duties. It establishes the medal as a national honor for those who make the ultimate sacrifice in service to their communities and the nation.

GroupImpactMechanismScale
GroupFamilies of fallen law enforcement officers and first respondersImpactProvides national recognition and honor for their loved one's sacrifice.MechanismFormal presidential issuance of a medal.ScaleIndividual, but with national symbolic significance.
GroupLaw enforcement and first responder communitiesImpactEnhances morale and public recognition of their service and risks.MechanismCreation of a prestigious national award.ScaleBroad, symbolic.

Supporters argue

Supporters argue this medal fills a gap in national recognition for the unique sacrifices made by law enforcement and first responders, providing a meaningful tribute to their service and comfort to their grieving families. It acknowledges the profound debt of gratitude owed to these individuals.

Critics contend

No specific opposition is typically raised against the concept of honoring fallen heroes, though some might question the necessity of a new medal when other forms of recognition, such as the Public Safety Officer Medal of Valor, already exist.

Tradeoffs

The primary tension is balancing the desire for broad recognition with the need for specific, meaningful criteria to ensure the medal's prestige and avoid duplication of existing honors.

Section 2(b)

Eligibility Criteria and Exception for Wrongdoing

prominently featuredmoderately complex

This section defines eligibility for the medal to include any local, State, Tribal, territorial, or Federal law enforcement officer or first responder killed in the line of duty. Crucially, it establishes an exception: those subject to an 'official finding of wrongdoing' are ineligible. The newly formed Commission is tasked with investigating such cases and making a final determination on eligibility, defining 'official finding of wrongdoing' as acting outside the scope of duties or agency policy.

Section 2(c)

Establishment and Responsibilities of the Commission

prominently featuredstraightforward

This provision establishes a 12-member Commission, appointed by the President, consisting of law enforcement officers, first responders, and representatives of relevant organizations. The Commission's responsibilities include advising on medal design, promoting its establishment, determining presentation methods, making final eligibility determinations in cases of alleged wrongdoing, and advising on eligibility criteria. Members serve 5-year terms, are eligible for two terms, and are unpaid.

Section 2(c)(6)

Designation of Initial Medal Recipients

mentioned in summarystraightforward

This provision explicitly names three individuals as the initial recipients of the Medal of Sacrifice: Deputy Ralph 'Butch' Waller (Badge #8434), Deputy Ignacio 'Dan' Diaz (Badge #7637), and Deputy Luis Paez (Badge #3882). This ensures that the first awards are made promptly upon the Commission's establishment, providing immediate recognition to specific fallen heroes.

About this analysis. AI-Generated from the official bill text and available committee reports. Gaps in available data are noted explicitly. Verify important details with the official Congress.gov record.

On this page

  • Executive summary
  • Key provisions
  • Follow the money
  • Critical analysis
  • Questions to ask
Ask Ledger AI about this